Press Release

Federal Court Remands Xerox Infringement Suit to District Court For
Determination of Validity
MILPITAS, Calif., Feb. 21 /PRNewswire-FirstCall/ -- Palm, Inc. (Nasdaq:
PALM) today announced that the United States Court of Appeals for the
Federal Circuit affirmed a decision by the District Court of the Western
District of New York that Palm infringed a Xerox Corp. patent. But the
Court of Appeals also remanded the case back to the District Court to
examine the validity of the patent in question.
Xerox filed the suit in April 1997 alleging that Palm's Graffiti(R) handwriting
recognition software infringed a Xerox United States patent relating to
computerized recognition of handwriting.
In remanding the case to the District Court, the Court of Appeals yesterday
asked the lower court to conduct a complete validity analysis of Xerox's
patent in question. While the Court of Appeals affirmed the District Court's
conclusion that Palm infringes the claims of the patent, it noted that
the infringement was based on a broad construction of the patent, which
"has implications for the issue of validity." The Court of Appeals
stated in its opinion that Palm "has made strong arguments that the
asserted claims, as construed, are invalid . . ."
"We are delighted that the Court of Appeals has overturned the summary
judgment with respect to the validity of the patent," said Eric Benhamou,
Palm chairman and chief executive officer. "This ruling recognizes
the strength of Palm's arguments with respect to the fundamental question
of validity."
About Palm, Inc.
Information about Palm, Inc. is available at http://www.palm.com/aboutpalm
.
NOTE: Graffiti is a registered trademark and Palm is a trademark of Palm,
Inc.
SOURCE Palm, Inc.
|